Submit a request
Home › Insights › Real Estate

The Innocent Purchaser’s Dilemma: Can You Lose Land You Bought in Good Faith?

Who Owns the Land? · Part 3 of 8  See the series

Pre­vi­ously, in Part 2: what a title deed is worth once it is chal­lenged. Now the harder ques­tion: what hap­pens to the buyer who did everything right? Next, in Part 4: we step into the auc­tion room.

A doc­tor bought a res­id­en­tial prop­erty in Na­k­uru in 2013 for KES 16.1 mil­lion and was re­gistered as pro­pri­etor in 2015. Ten years later, the En­vir­on­ment and Land Court can­celled his title be­cause the prop­erty was a gov­ern­ment house on land re­served for the Re­gional Veter­in­ary In­vest­ig­a­tion Labor­at­ory. The En­vir­on­ment and Land Court did one more thing: it ordered the per­son who sold him the land to re­fund the pur­chase price and costs of the pur­chase, KES 17,440,911.10, with in­terest (Otara v Mukur­iah & 4 oth­ers [2025] KEELC 5001 (KLR)). The vendor has ap­pealed, and the Court of Ap­peal de­clined to stay the judg­ment in May 2026 (Mukur­iah v Otara & 4 oth­ers [2026] KECA 905 (KLR)).

The case cap­tures the di­lemma this art­icle ad­dresses. Can a pur­chaser who paid full value, searched the re­gister and knew noth­ing of any wrong­do­ing lose the land? The an­swer is yes. But the bona fide pur­chaser doc­trine has not dis­ap­peared. It has been put back in its proper place, and the pur­chaser’s in­no­cence still mat­ters a great deal, though more of­ten to the ques­tion of who pays than to the ques­tion of who keeps the land.

The Su­preme Court in Dina Man­age­ment Ltd v County Gov­ern­ment of Mom­basa & 5 oth­ers [2023] KESC 30 (KLR) cited two for­mu­la­tions. The first is the Ugandan Court of Ap­peal’s in Katende v Har­idar & Com­pany Ltd [2008] 2 EA 173, which sets out seven ele­ments: the pur­chaser holds a cer­ti­fic­ate of title, bought in good faith, had no know­ledge of the fraud, paid valu­able con­sid­er­a­tion, the vendors had ap­par­ent valid title, the pur­chaser bought without no­tice of any fraud, and was not party to any fraud. The Court of Ap­peal ap­plied it in Lawrence P. Mukiri Mun­gai, At­tor­ney of Fran­cis Mur­oki Mwaura v At­tor­ney Gen­eral & 4 oth­ers [2017] KECA 698 (KLR).

The second is the Court of Ap­peal’s de­cision in Kamere v Lands Re­gis­trar, Kaji­ado [2015] KECA 644 (KLR): the pur­chaser “must prove that he had ac­quired a valid and legal title, secondly, that he car­ried out the ne­ces­sary due di­li­gence to de­term­ine the law­ful owner from whom he ac­quired a le­git­im­ate title, and thirdly that he paid valu­able con­sid­er­a­tion”.

The Kamere for­mu­la­tion con­tains the seed of what fol­lowed. Its first ele­ment is a “valid and legal title”. A pur­chaser who can­not show that can­not be a bona fide pur­chaser in the pro­tec­ted sense, how­ever hon­est.

The Su­preme Court’s fullest state­ment is in Sehmi & an­other v Tara­bana Com­pany Ltd & 5 oth­ers [2025] KESC 21 (KLR). Four points stand out:

  1. The bur­den of proof “lies upon the per­son claim­ing to be a bona fide pur­chaser”.
  2. In­no­cence is not mere ig­nor­ance. Re­stat­ing its de­cision in Torino En­ter­prises Ltd v At­tor­ney Gen­eral [2023] KESC 79 (KLR), the Su­preme Court said that the doc­trine “de­notes a pur­chaser who ex­er­cised due di­li­gence”.
  3. The doc­trine is a de­fence against equit­able claims. It “only pro­tects the pur­chaser against those basing their claims upon an equit­able in­terest”. This re­states what the Court of Ap­peal had held in Arthi High­way De­velopers Ltd v West End Butchery Ltd & 6 oth­ers [2015] KECA 816 (KLR), that pro­tec­tion runs “only against equit­able in­terests” and “never en­abled a pur­chaser to take free from legal rights”.
  4. Fi­nally, there can be no pro­tect­able “pur­chaser of an il­legal title without no­tice of such il­leg­al­ity”, and the doc­trine “can­not be in­voked to pro­tect a title to an il­leg­ally ac­quired pub­lic land”. A pur­chaser can­not claim pro­tec­tion, the Su­preme Court said, even if he was not aware of the il­leg­al­ity.

The reason is struc­tural, not moral. The bona fide pur­chaser doc­trine de­cides con­tests between a legal title and an earlier equit­able claim. It al­lows a pur­chaser of the legal es­tate to take free of equit­ies he did not know about. It was never a means of cre­at­ing a legal title out of noth­ing. Where the vendor’s title was void (be­cause the land was not avail­able for al­loc­a­tion, the al­loc­a­tion pro­cess was un­law­ful, a link in the chain was forged, or the vendor had no au­thor­ity to sell), the pur­chaser has no legal es­tate for the doc­trine to pro­tect.

The Court of Ap­peal had ac­cep­ted that res­ult long be­fore Dina. In Ochi­eng & an­other v Ochi­eng & 2 oth­ers [1996] KECA 205 (KLR), where a char­gee’s sale was void for want of proved stat­utory no­tice, the Court of Ap­peal ac­know­ledged that its de­cision meant “an in­no­cent pur­chaser for value be­ing de­prived of the title”. In Wam­bui v Mwangi & 3 oth­ers [2021] KECA 144 (KLR), where land had been sold at auc­tion in ex­e­cu­tion of a de­cree ob­tained by a fic­ti­tious plaintiff, the earlier title pre­vailed “not­with­stand­ing that the ap­pel­lant may have had no no­tice”.

It would be a ser­i­ous mis­read­ing to con­clude that the pur­chaser’s po­s­i­tion is hope­less. Three cat­egor­ies of cases are de­cided in the pur­chaser’s fa­vour.

  1. Where the root is law­ful. The Su­preme Court in Fanikiwa Ltd & 3 oth­ers v Sirikwa Squat­ters Group & 17 oth­ers [2023] KESC 105 (KLR) up­held a chain of titles and held that where the root is law­ful, “the ques­tion of whether such third parties were in­no­cent pur­chasers for value without no­tice should not arise”. The title stands on its own.
  2. Where the com­pet­ing claim is equit­able. In Free­dom Lim­ited v Mbarak [2026] KESC 2 (KLR), the Su­preme Court de­scribed the es­tate’s un­re­gistered in­terest un­der an un­com­pleted sale as “only an equit­able or be­ne­fi­cial in­terest”, “sus­cept­ible to a su­per­ior claim by a bona fide pur­chaser for value without no­tice” as long as the pur­chase is not tain­ted by il­leg­al­ity. It re­mit­ted the case to the En­vir­on­ment and Land Court for a fresh hear­ing of the fac­tual ques­tions.
  3. Where the chal­lenger can­not prove the de­fect. In Mun­yanya v Keya [2024] KECA 1831 (KLR), the chal­lenger raised doubts but not “very co­gent evid­ence”, and the pur­chaser’s title was up­held. In Kanyua v Munene & 2 oth­ers [2026] KECA 94 (KLR), pur­chasers from a pro­pri­etor who held un­der a con­firmed grant kept their titles be­cause fraud was “not proven”. In Mui­gai v Ali & 3 oth­ers [2026] KEELC 16 (KLR), a double al­loc­a­tion, the En­vir­on­ment and Land Court up­held the earlier lease and sale and de­clared the pur­chaser in pos­ses­sion a bona fide owner by reason of pur­chase.

Be­cause due di­li­gence is now an ele­ment of in­no­cence, the ques­tion of what should have put the pur­chaser on in­quiry has be­come cent­ral. The de­cided cases give con­crete guid­ance.

  • Oc­cu­pa­tion by someone else is no­tice. In Torino, the De­part­ment of De­fence’s oc­cu­pa­tion “soun­ded a warn­ing of ‘buyer be aware’”.
  • Pub­lic use vis­ible on the ground is no­tice. In Shah & an­other v Kenya Na­tional High­ways Au­thor­ity [2023] KECA 404 (KLR), there were “tell­tale signs in the his­tory of the suit prop­er­ties” of a road re­serve.
  • In­con­sist­en­cies in the title doc­u­ments are no­tice. In Galaxy Re­altors Ltd v Kenya Forest Ser­vice [2024] KECA 1304 (KLR), the lease ran from 1998 and the re­gister was opened in 2000, be­fore the 2001 no­tice that pur­por­ted to de-gaz­ette the forest (a no­tice the High Court later quashed). These in­con­sist­en­cies cast ser­i­ous doubt on the title, and the pur­chaser “can­not hide be­hind the doc­trine of bona fide pur­chaser for value”.
  • The know­ledge of those be­hind a pur­chas­ing com­pany is the com­pany’s know­ledge. In Frann In­vest­ment Ltd v Kenya Anti-Cor­rup­tion Com­mis­sion & 6 oth­ers [2024] KECA 714 (KLR), the land was a cus­toms house and the pur­chas­ing com­pany was owned by a former cus­toms of­ficer and his fam­ily, who knew it; the trans­fer “was not made in good faith”.
  • Un­usual con­trac­tual pro­tec­tion can be no­tice. In Tele­posta Pen­sion Scheme Re­gistered Trust­ees v In­ter­coun­tries Ex­port­ers Ltd & 5 oth­ers [2024] KECA 870 (KLR), the Court of Ap­peal re­lied on the fact that the selling bank had given the buyer an in­dem­nity as in­dic­at­ing aware­ness of a de­fect.

This is where in­no­cence counts most, and where the case law is least settled.

  1. The vendor. The Court of Ap­peal has said that the doc­trine, “at its most char­it­able”, per­mits the suc­cessor “to look to the pre­de­cessor in title” and, ex­cep­tion­ally, to a com­pli­cit gov­ern­ment agency (Shah v KeNHA). In Otara, the vendor was joined and ordered to re­fund the full price and the costs of the pur­chase, with in­terest, in the same suit. In Maina & an­other v Maina & 4 oth­ers [2024] KEELC 5827 (KLR), the pur­chasers were told they were “at liberty to seek rem­edy for dam­ages as against the 1st De­fend­ant in a sep­ar­ate suit”. In other cases, the judg­ment is si­lent, and the pur­chaser leaves with noth­ing but a cause of ac­tion.
  2. The char­gee or other seller. Where the land was sold by a bank, the pur­chaser’s rem­edy lies against the bank: “Her rem­edy is against the bank primar­ily to ob­tain a re­fund of the con­sid­er­a­tion paid” (Ochi­eng); the title be­ing “worth­less”, the rem­edy “can only lie against the Bank” (Tele­posta). Whether Dina and Sehmi ap­ply at all to a title ac­quired through a char­gee’s stat­utory power of sale is now be­fore the Su­preme Court, which cer­ti­fied that ques­tion for ap­peal in Tele­posta Pen­sion Scheme Trust­ees Re­gistered v In­ter­coun­tries Im­port­ers and Ex­port­ers Lim­ited & 5 oth­ers [2026] KESC 27 (KLR). Parts 4 and 5 of our series deal with auc­tion pur­chasers in de­tail.
  3. The State. Sec­tion 81 of the Land Re­gis­tra­tion Act, 2012 en­titles a per­son suf­fer­ing dam­age by reason of rec­ti­fic­a­tion of the re­gister to in­dem­nity, ex­clud­ing any­one who caused or sub­stan­tially con­trib­uted to the dam­age “by fraud or neg­li­gence” (sec­tion 81(2)). The Su­preme Court has not de­cided whether, or how far, an in­no­cent pur­chaser whose title is can­celled un­der Dina may claim com­pens­a­tion; in March 2026 it de­clined to cer­tify for ap­peal a case that had raised that ques­tion (Frann In­vest­ment Lim­ited v Kenya Anti-Cor­rup­tion Com­mis­sion & 6 oth­ers [2026] KESC 31 (KLR)), hold­ing that the is­sues had already been settled in its earlier de­cisions. The ques­tion of State com­pens­a­tion for in­no­cent pur­chasers re­mains open, and it is ex­amined in Part 8.

There is also a risk in the other dir­ec­tion. A pur­chaser who loses the land may be ordered to pay dam­ages for tres­pass to the true owner, as in Kamau & an­other v Munene & 2 oth­ers [2024] KEELC 4769 (KLR), where KES 5 mil­lion was awar­ded against a pur­chaser who said he had paid KES 28 mil­lion for the land.

For pur­chasers, the an­swer to the di­lemma lies in pre­par­a­tion and in plead­ing. Be­fore buy­ing, the pur­chaser should do the in­quir­ies the courts treat as part of in­no­cence (Part 7 sets them out). The sale agree­ment should con­tain en­force­able war­ranties of title and an in­dem­nity from a vendor worth su­ing, and where pos­sible, a re­ten­tion or es­crow. If the title is later at­tacked, the pur­chaser should join the vendor and plead an al­tern­at­ive claim for a re­fund, dam­ages and in­dem­nity in the same suit, so that the court can do what it did in Otara rather than leave the pur­chaser to start again.

For ad­voc­ates act­ing for pur­chasers, the re­cord of due di­li­gence is evid­ence. The searches, the plan­ning and sur­vey in­quir­ies, the in­spec­tion re­port and the cor­res­pond­ence with the vendor are what will prove in­no­cence if it is ever in is­sue, and Sehmi puts the bur­den of prov­ing it on the pur­chaser.

Yes, you can lose land you bought in good faith. Since Dina and Sehmi, hon­esty alone will not save a title whose root was un­law­ful. But the in­no­cent pur­chaser is not de­fence­less. A buyer whose title rests on a law­ful root needs no de­fence at all, and a buyer fa­cing a chal­lenger without cred­ible evid­ence wins. A buyer who loses has a claim for com­pens­a­tion against the vendor, the bank or po­ten­tially the State. What de­cides the out­come is pre­par­a­tion: the due di­li­gence done be­fore pur­chase, the pro­tec­tions writ­ten into the con­tract, and the way the claim is pleaded when the title is at­tacked.

Part 4: Buy­ing Land at a Pub­lic Auc­tion. Does the fall of the ham­mer still make the buyer safe?

If you have bought land whose title is now be­ing ques­tioned, or you are about to buy and want to be sure you are pro­tec­ted, OK Law can guide you through both the de­fence of your title and the re­cov­ery of what you paid.

Follow the series

Get the next part of "Who Owns the Land?" and our other in­sights by email as soon as they are pub­lished.

Topics (optional):
You'll be subscribed straight away and we'll email you a confirmation. Unsubscribe at any time with one click.

Related insights

Tell us about your matter

A part­ner re­views every re­quest and comes back to you.

Submit a request