The Innocent Purchaser’s Dilemma: Can You Lose Land You Bought in Good Faith?
Previously, in Part 2: what a title deed is worth once it is challenged. Now the harder question: what happens to the buyer who did everything right? Next, in Part 4: we step into the auction room.
A doctor bought a residential property in Nakuru in 2013 for KES 16.1 million and was registered as proprietor in 2015. Ten years later, the Environment and Land Court cancelled his title because the property was a government house on land reserved for the Regional Veterinary Investigation Laboratory. The Environment and Land Court did one more thing: it ordered the person who sold him the land to refund the purchase price and costs of the purchase, KES 17,440,911.10, with interest (Otara v Mukuriah & 4 others [2025] KEELC 5001 (KLR)). The vendor has appealed, and the Court of Appeal declined to stay the judgment in May 2026 (Mukuriah v Otara & 4 others [2026] KECA 905 (KLR)).
The case captures the dilemma this article addresses. Can a purchaser who paid full value, searched the register and knew nothing of any wrongdoing lose the land? The answer is yes. But the bona fide purchaser doctrine has not disappeared. It has been put back in its proper place, and the purchaser’s innocence still matters a great deal, though more often to the question of who pays than to the question of who keeps the land.
The Doctrine as Kenyan Courts State It
The Supreme Court in Dina Management Ltd v County Government of Mombasa & 5 others [2023] KESC 30 (KLR) cited two formulations. The first is the Ugandan Court of Appeal’s in Katende v Haridar & Company Ltd [2008] 2 EA 173, which sets out seven elements: the purchaser holds a certificate of title, bought in good faith, had no knowledge of the fraud, paid valuable consideration, the vendors had apparent valid title, the purchaser bought without notice of any fraud, and was not party to any fraud. The Court of Appeal applied it in Lawrence P. Mukiri Mungai, Attorney of Francis Muroki Mwaura v Attorney General & 4 others [2017] KECA 698 (KLR).
The second is the Court of Appeal’s decision in Kamere v Lands Registrar, Kajiado [2015] KECA 644 (KLR): the purchaser “must prove that he had acquired a valid and legal title, secondly, that he carried out the necessary due diligence to determine the lawful owner from whom he acquired a legitimate title, and thirdly that he paid valuable consideration”.
The Kamere formulation contains the seed of what followed. Its first element is a “valid and legal title”. A purchaser who cannot show that cannot be a bona fide purchaser in the protected sense, however honest.
What Sehmi Added
The Supreme Court’s fullest statement is in Sehmi & another v Tarabana Company Ltd & 5 others [2025] KESC 21 (KLR). Four points stand out:
- The burden of proof “lies upon the person claiming to be a bona fide purchaser”.
- Innocence is not mere ignorance. Restating its decision in Torino Enterprises Ltd v Attorney General [2023] KESC 79 (KLR), the Supreme Court said that the doctrine “denotes a purchaser who exercised due diligence”.
- The doctrine is a defence against equitable claims. It “only protects the purchaser against those basing their claims upon an equitable interest”. This restates what the Court of Appeal had held in Arthi Highway Developers Ltd v West End Butchery Ltd & 6 others [2015] KECA 816 (KLR), that protection runs “only against equitable interests” and “never enabled a purchaser to take free from legal rights”.
- Finally, there can be no protectable “purchaser of an illegal title without notice of such illegality”, and the doctrine “cannot be invoked to protect a title to an illegally acquired public land”. A purchaser cannot claim protection, the Supreme Court said, even if he was not aware of the illegality.
Why an Innocent Purchaser Can Still Lose the Land
The reason is structural, not moral. The bona fide purchaser doctrine decides contests between a legal title and an earlier equitable claim. It allows a purchaser of the legal estate to take free of equities he did not know about. It was never a means of creating a legal title out of nothing. Where the vendor’s title was void (because the land was not available for allocation, the allocation process was unlawful, a link in the chain was forged, or the vendor had no authority to sell), the purchaser has no legal estate for the doctrine to protect.
The Court of Appeal had accepted that result long before Dina. In Ochieng & another v Ochieng & 2 others [1996] KECA 205 (KLR), where a chargee’s sale was void for want of proved statutory notice, the Court of Appeal acknowledged that its decision meant “an innocent purchaser for value being deprived of the title”. In Wambui v Mwangi & 3 others [2021] KECA 144 (KLR), where land had been sold at auction in execution of a decree obtained by a fictitious plaintiff, the earlier title prevailed “notwithstanding that the appellant may have had no notice”.
When Innocence Still Wins
It would be a serious misreading to conclude that the purchaser’s position is hopeless. Three categories of cases are decided in the purchaser’s favour.
- Where the root is lawful. The Supreme Court in Fanikiwa Ltd & 3 others v Sirikwa Squatters Group & 17 others [2023] KESC 105 (KLR) upheld a chain of titles and held that where the root is lawful, “the question of whether such third parties were innocent purchasers for value without notice should not arise”. The title stands on its own.
- Where the competing claim is equitable. In Freedom Limited v Mbarak [2026] KESC 2 (KLR), the Supreme Court described the estate’s unregistered interest under an uncompleted sale as “only an equitable or beneficial interest”, “susceptible to a superior claim by a bona fide purchaser for value without notice” as long as the purchase is not tainted by illegality. It remitted the case to the Environment and Land Court for a fresh hearing of the factual questions.
- Where the challenger cannot prove the defect. In Munyanya v Keya [2024] KECA 1831 (KLR), the challenger raised doubts but not “very cogent evidence”, and the purchaser’s title was upheld. In Kanyua v Munene & 2 others [2026] KECA 94 (KLR), purchasers from a proprietor who held under a confirmed grant kept their titles because fraud was “not proven”. In Muigai v Ali & 3 others [2026] KEELC 16 (KLR), a double allocation, the Environment and Land Court upheld the earlier lease and sale and declared the purchaser in possession a bona fide owner by reason of purchase.
Notice: What the Courts Treat as a Warning
Because due diligence is now an element of innocence, the question of what should have put the purchaser on inquiry has become central. The decided cases give concrete guidance.
- Occupation by someone else is notice. In Torino, the Department of Defence’s occupation “sounded a warning of ‘buyer be aware’”.
- Public use visible on the ground is notice. In Shah & another v Kenya National Highways Authority [2023] KECA 404 (KLR), there were “telltale signs in the history of the suit properties” of a road reserve.
- Inconsistencies in the title documents are notice. In Galaxy Realtors Ltd v Kenya Forest Service [2024] KECA 1304 (KLR), the lease ran from 1998 and the register was opened in 2000, before the 2001 notice that purported to de-gazette the forest (a notice the High Court later quashed). These inconsistencies cast serious doubt on the title, and the purchaser “cannot hide behind the doctrine of bona fide purchaser for value”.
- The knowledge of those behind a purchasing company is the company’s knowledge. In Frann Investment Ltd v Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission & 6 others [2024] KECA 714 (KLR), the land was a customs house and the purchasing company was owned by a former customs officer and his family, who knew it; the transfer “was not made in good faith”.
- Unusual contractual protection can be notice. In Teleposta Pension Scheme Registered Trustees v Intercountries Exporters Ltd & 5 others [2024] KECA 870 (KLR), the Court of Appeal relied on the fact that the selling bank had given the buyer an indemnity as indicating awareness of a defect.
Remedies: Who Pays When the Purchaser Loses
This is where innocence counts most, and where the case law is least settled.
- The vendor. The Court of Appeal has said that the doctrine, “at its most charitable”, permits the successor “to look to the predecessor in title” and, exceptionally, to a complicit government agency (Shah v KeNHA). In Otara, the vendor was joined and ordered to refund the full price and the costs of the purchase, with interest, in the same suit. In Maina & another v Maina & 4 others [2024] KEELC 5827 (KLR), the purchasers were told they were “at liberty to seek remedy for damages as against the 1st Defendant in a separate suit”. In other cases, the judgment is silent, and the purchaser leaves with nothing but a cause of action.
- The chargee or other seller. Where the land was sold by a bank, the purchaser’s remedy lies against the bank: “Her remedy is against the bank primarily to obtain a refund of the consideration paid” (Ochieng); the title being “worthless”, the remedy “can only lie against the Bank” (Teleposta). Whether Dina and Sehmi apply at all to a title acquired through a chargee’s statutory power of sale is now before the Supreme Court, which certified that question for appeal in Teleposta Pension Scheme Trustees Registered v Intercountries Importers and Exporters Limited & 5 others [2026] KESC 27 (KLR). Parts 4 and 5 of our series deal with auction purchasers in detail.
- The State. Section 81 of the Land Registration Act, 2012 entitles a person suffering damage by reason of rectification of the register to indemnity, excluding anyone who caused or substantially contributed to the damage “by fraud or negligence” (section 81(2)). The Supreme Court has not decided whether, or how far, an innocent purchaser whose title is cancelled under Dina may claim compensation; in March 2026 it declined to certify for appeal a case that had raised that question (Frann Investment Limited v Kenya Anti-Corruption Commission & 6 others [2026] KESC 31 (KLR)), holding that the issues had already been settled in its earlier decisions. The question of State compensation for innocent purchasers remains open, and it is examined in Part 8.
There is also a risk in the other direction. A purchaser who loses the land may be ordered to pay damages for trespass to the true owner, as in Kamau & another v Munene & 2 others [2024] KEELC 4769 (KLR), where KES 5 million was awarded against a purchaser who said he had paid KES 28 million for the land.
Practical Implications
For purchasers, the answer to the dilemma lies in preparation and in pleading. Before buying, the purchaser should do the inquiries the courts treat as part of innocence (Part 7 sets them out). The sale agreement should contain enforceable warranties of title and an indemnity from a vendor worth suing, and where possible, a retention or escrow. If the title is later attacked, the purchaser should join the vendor and plead an alternative claim for a refund, damages and indemnity in the same suit, so that the court can do what it did in Otara rather than leave the purchaser to start again.
For advocates acting for purchasers, the record of due diligence is evidence. The searches, the planning and survey inquiries, the inspection report and the correspondence with the vendor are what will prove innocence if it is ever in issue, and Sehmi puts the burden of proving it on the purchaser.
The Bottom Line
Yes, you can lose land you bought in good faith. Since Dina and Sehmi, honesty alone will not save a title whose root was unlawful. But the innocent purchaser is not defenceless. A buyer whose title rests on a lawful root needs no defence at all, and a buyer facing a challenger without credible evidence wins. A buyer who loses has a claim for compensation against the vendor, the bank or potentially the State. What decides the outcome is preparation: the due diligence done before purchase, the protections written into the contract, and the way the claim is pleaded when the title is attacked.
Next in the Series
Part 4: Buying Land at a Public Auction. Does the fall of the hammer still make the buyer safe?
If you have bought land whose title is now being questioned, or you are about to buy and want to be sure you are protected, OK Law can guide you through both the defence of your title and the recovery of what you paid.
Disclaimer: Who Owns the Land? is a series by OK Law Advocates LLP on titles, purchases, and public auctions after Dina Management. It is a general commentary on the law as of the date of this publication and is not legal advice on any particular transaction. To discuss what it means for your land, purchase or security, contact our Real Estate team. Specific advice should be obtained on the facts of each case from Luka Ome (luka@oklawllp.com) or OK Law Advocates LLP (enquiries@oklawllp.com).
Follow the series
Get the next part of "Who Owns the Land?" and our other insights by email as soon as they are published.
