Buying Land at a Public Auction in Kenya: Does Dina Management Change the Rules?
Previously, in Parts 1 to 3: the private purchaser. Now the auction room, where many buyers assume the fall of the hammer makes them safe. Next, in Part 5: chargee sales, and the bank sale appeal now pending before the Supreme Court.
The fall of the hammer has long been treated as the moment when the auction purchaser becomes safe. The owner’s right to redeem is gone, the purchaser is not expected to look behind the auctioneer’s conditions of sale, and any complaint about how the sale was run becomes a claim for money against someone else. Since the Supreme Court’s decision in Dina Management Ltd v County Government of Mombasa & 5 others [2023] KESC 30 (KLR) (“Dina Management”), buyers, lenders and auctioneers have asked whether that is still true.
The answer depends on what kind of auction it was and what kind of defect is alleged. This article maps the ground: the different kinds of public sale in Kenya, the legal regime that governs each, and the line the courts have drawn between a defect in the sale and a defect in the thing sold. Part 5 then examines the most contested category, the chargee’s sale under section 99 of the Land Act, 2012, and the appeal now pending before the Supreme Court.
Not One Auction, but Several
It is a mistake to treat “auction purchaser” as a single legal category. At least four regimes are in play.
- A chargee’s sale is a sale by a bank or other chargee exercising the statutory power of sale under sections 96 to 99 of the Land Act. The court is not involved unless someone sues. Section 99 of the Land Act gives the purchaser specific statutory protection.
- A judicial sale is a sale in execution of a court decree under sections 44, 48 and 49 of the Civil Procedure Act (the “CPA”) and Order 22 of the Civil Procedure Rules, 2010 (the “CPR”), conducted by a court officer or court-appointed auctioneer and confirmed by the court.
- A statutory sale by a public authority is a sale by a county government for unpaid rates or by the Kenya Revenue Authority for unpaid tax. Under the repealed Rating Act (Cap. 267), rates sales were in substance judicial sales; under the National Rating Act, 2024 (the “NRA”) and the Tax Procedures Act, 2015 (the “TPA”), the authority may sell without a court order.
- A sale of estate property may take any of these forms, but carries the additional requirements of the Law of Succession Act (the “LSA”).
The protection each regime gives the purchaser is different, and so is the route by which a sale can be challenged.
The Constant: Process Versus Root
Across all four regimes the decided cases draw the same fundamental line, which we will call “the line between the process and the root”.
A defect in the process of sale (notices, valuation, advertisement, the necessity or propriety of the sale) is generally cured as against an innocent purchaser once the sale is complete, and the owner is left with damages. That is the policy of section 99(4) of the Land Act, and it is reflected in the procedure for court sales under Order 22 of the CPR.
A defect in the root (the seller had no valid title, no valid charge, no valid decree, or no authority to sell) is not cured. The purchaser acquires only what the seller had to give.
Dina Management did not create that line. It intensified the scrutiny of the root. Once a court finds that the land was unlawfully acquired at its origin, the auction does not create an interest that did not exist.
Court-ordered Sales
Section 44(1) of the CPA makes “all property belonging to a judgment debtor” liable to attachment and sale. Once a sale of immovable property “has become absolute”, section 48 of the CPA deems the property to have vested in the purchaser from the time of sale. Order 22 rule 77(1) of the CPR provides that the court shall confirm the sale where no application to set it aside is made or succeeds, “and thereupon the sale shall become absolute in so far as the interest of the judgment-debtor in the property sold is concerned”.
Two features of that scheme protect the purchaser. First, the procedure for challenging a sale is a closed code. In Stanley Ng’ethe Kinyanjui v Tony Ketter & 5 others [2015] KECA 790 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that the execution rules “represent a complete code” and that a challenger who did not use them could not fall back on the court’s inherent or constitutional powers. The sale was upheld. Secondly, a sale may be set aside for “material irregularity or fraud in publishing or conducting it” (Order 22 rule 75 of the CPR), but only where the applicant shows substantial injury.
The scheme equally limits the purchaser’s protection. The words “in so far as the interest of the judgment-debtor in the property sold is concerned” in Order 22 rule 77(1) of the CPR mean that confirmation passes only what the judgment debtor had. Order 22 rule 76 of the CPR gives the purchaser the right to set the sale aside where “the judgment-debtor had no saleable interest”. Where a sale is set aside under Order 22 rule 75 of the CPR, rule 78 entitles the purchaser to an order for repayment of the purchase money, with or without interest. In Mehuba Gelan Keul & 2 others v Abdulkadir Shariff Abdirahim & 4 others [2015] KEHC 7265 (KLR), an execution sale was set aside under Order 22 rule 75 of the CPR because the property was already charged to a bank, and the High Court ordered the purchaser’s money repaid with interest at 18.5% a year.
Where the proceedings behind the sale were themselves void, the purchaser takes nothing. In Wambui v Mwangi & 3 others [2021] KECA 144 (KLR), land was sold at auction in execution of a decree fraudulently obtained by a plaintiff using another person’s identity. The Court of Appeal held that “no sanctionable benefits could flow” from the void proceedings and that the auction purchaser’s title “stood vitiated by the same nullity”. The sub-purchaser lost the land, though the trial court’s money award in its favour against the auction purchaser stood. In Dhiman v Shah [2025] KECA 1264 (KLR), the Court of Appeal held that once an ex parte judgment was set aside, the auction sale and the vesting order made on it fell “by operation of law” and were “null and void”. In that case the purchaser was the decree-holder himself, so the decision does not settle the position of an unconnected bidder.
Good faith does not always save a judicial sale even where the defect is one of process. In Nationwide Finance Co Ltd v Meck Industries Ltd & another [2001] KEHC 160 (KLR), the High Court set aside an execution sale held without a reserve price, holding that its power to set aside an irregular sale is not affected by the fact that the property was sold to a bona fide purchaser. The Court of Appeal later dismissed the purchaser’s appeal, as recorded in George Gikubu Mbuthia v Consolidated Bank of Kenya Limited [2016] KECA 768 (KLR).
Certificates of Sale and Vesting Orders
Purchasers often assume that a court document is an answer to any later challenge. It is not.
A certificate of sale under Order 22 rule 79 of the CPR records that the sale has become absolute. Section 65 of the Land Registration Act, 2012 (the “LRA”) allows a person entitled “by virtue of any order or certificate of sale” to be registered as proprietor. But the certificate records the sale of the judgment-debtor’s interest; it does not enlarge it.
Vesting orders are more problematic. In Electrical Marketing (Wholesale) Ltd v Nairobi City County & 2 others [2019] KEELC 1982 (KLR), the Environment and Land Court observed that vesting orders are made “with a view to vesting movable property on a purchaser”, and that “a vesting order ought not to have been issued after the sale of the land”. It set aside the sale and the vesting order together. Dhiman shows that a vesting order falls with the decree that supports it.
Section 25(1) of the LRA protects rights acquired “by an order of court”, but only “except as provided in this Act”, which leaves section 26(1)(b) available. A vesting order or certificate of sale does not cure a defect in the root of title.
County Rates and Other Statutory Sales
Until 24th December 2024, rates were enforced under the Rating Act (Cap. 267). A rating authority sued in the subordinate court and executed the decree under the CPA, or applied to the High Court for an order for sale. Rates sales were therefore judicial sales, and the courts set them aside where the statutory steps were missed.
In Electrical Marketing, the land was sold for rates without proper service of the summons, notice of the judgment, a registered prohibitory order, a valuation or payment of the proceeds into court. The court held that there were “material irregularities and fraud in the conduct of the sale”, and it rejected the argument that damages were the owner’s only remedy. In Dhanji & another v County Government of Mombasa & 3 others [2024] KEELC 6001 (KLR), the County could not show that the demand had been served, and the sale had been advertised without the notice being fixed on the property. The court held that “a good title did not pass”, upheld the cancellation of the purchasers’ title, and upheld an award of KES 5 million in damages for the owner’s wrongful eviction. The trial court had found that the purchasers knew of the pending proceedings.
The NRA (No. 15 of 2024) repealed Cap. 267. Section 19(3)(d) of the NRA now allows a county, after demand and default, to auction the rateable property at the current market value in accordance with the provided procedures, with the details left to county legislation (section 19(4)). Section 40(5) of the TPA similarly allows the Commissioner of the Kenya Revenue Authority to dispose of property charged for unpaid tax by public auction or private treaty without a court order.
Two observations follow from the statutes. First, neither Act contains a provision like section 99 of the Land Act protecting the purchaser from irregularities, so the purchaser depends on the authority’s strict compliance. Secondly, a sale that departs from the statutory steps is exposed to challenge as a title “acquired ... unprocedurally” under section 26(1)(b) of the LRA. Purchasers at county auctions should therefore satisfy themselves that the demand was properly served, the notice period expired, the property was valued, and the county’s own procedure was followed.
Estate Property
Land of a deceased person cannot be sold by anyone who lacks a grant (section 45 of the LSA), and an administrator may not sell immovable property before the grant is confirmed (section 82(b), proviso (ii)). Section 93 of the LSA protects transfers made to a purchaser “by a person to whom representation has been granted”, even if the grant is later revoked, but on its terms it does not protect sales by a person without a grant.
The courts have applied Dina Management to such sales. In Mbae & another v Mwamba & 5 others [2024] KEELC 215 (KLR), land was registered by transmission to a person who held no grant of representation, then subdivided and sold. The court held that the transfers were “unlawful and cannot be protected by the law”, and, citing Dina Management and Torino Enterprises Ltd v Attorney General [2023] KESC 79 (KLR), that “the bar has been set higher for innocent purchasers”. An appeal against that decision is pending in the Court of Appeal. In the chargee context, the Court of Appeal in Marteve Guest House Ltd v Njenga & 3 others [2022] KECA 539 (KLR) held, by a majority, that a bank’s auction was void where the chargor had died, the statutory notices had been served on her beneficiaries before they had obtained a grant, and fraud by the bank and the borrower was proved. Part 5 discusses that case.
What the Purchaser Should Do
For any public sale, the purchaser should ask two separate questions, and should not let a positive answer to the first stand in for the second.
- Was the sale properly authorised and conducted? For a court sale: a valid decree, a registered prohibitory order over the same land, a notification of sale, a reserve price based on a current valuation, and confirmation by the court. For a rates or tax sale: demand, service, expiry of the notice period, valuation and the prescribed procedure. For estate land: a grant, confirmed where a sale is involved.
- Did the seller (the judgment debtor, the ratepayer or the deceased) have a lawful title to begin with? That requires the same root-of-title inquiry as any private purchase: the register and its history, the allotment and survey records for allocated land, and inspection of the land for public use or third-party occupation (Part 7).
The Bottom Line
The fall of the hammer still protects the auction buyer, but only against what went wrong at the auction. It does not cure what was wrong before it: a seller with no title, a void decree, estate land sold without a grant, or a county that skipped the statutory steps. A certificate of sale or a vesting order will not change that. Bargains at auction are real, and so are the risks hidden behind them.
Next in the Series
Part 5: Chargee Sales and Section 99 of the Land Act. The bank sale the Supreme Court has agreed to decide, and what its answer could mean for every auction buyer and lender.
Disclaimer: Who Owns the Land? is a series by OK Law Advocates LLP on title, purchasers and public auctions after Dina Management. It is general commentary on the law as at the date hereof and is not legal advice on any particular transaction. To discuss what it means for your land, your purchase or your security, contact our Real Estate team. Specific advice should be obtained on the facts of each case from Luka Ome (luka@oklawllp.com) or OK Law Advocates LLP (enquiries@oklawllp.com).
Follow the series
Get the next part of "Who Owns the Land?" and our other insights by email as soon as they are published.
