Submit a request
Home › Insights › Real Estate

Buying Land at a Public Auction in Kenya: Does Dina Management Change the Rules?

Who Owns the Land? · Part 4 of 8  See the series

Pre­vi­ously, in Parts 1 to 3: the private pur­chaser. Now the auc­tion room, where many buy­ers as­sume the fall of the ham­mer makes them safe. Next, in Part 5: char­gee sales, and the bank sale ap­peal now pending be­fore the Su­preme Court.

The fall of the ham­mer has long been treated as the mo­ment when the auc­tion pur­chaser be­comes safe. The own­er’s right to re­deem is gone, the pur­chaser is not ex­pec­ted to look be­hind the auc­tion­eer’s con­di­tions of sale, and any com­plaint about how the sale was run be­comes a claim for money against someone else. Since the Su­preme Court’s de­cision in Dina Man­age­ment Ltd v County Gov­ern­ment of Mom­basa & 5 oth­ers [2023] KESC 30 (KLR) (“Dina Man­age­ment”), buy­ers, lenders and auc­tion­eers have asked whether that is still true.

The an­swer de­pends on what kind of auc­tion it was and what kind of de­fect is al­leged. This art­icle maps the ground: the dif­fer­ent kinds of pub­lic sale in Kenya, the legal re­gime that gov­erns each, and the line the courts have drawn between a de­fect in the sale and a de­fect in the thing sold. Part 5 then ex­am­ines the most con­tested cat­egory, the char­gee’s sale un­der sec­tion 99 of the Land Act, 2012, and the ap­peal now pending be­fore the Su­preme Court.

It is a mis­take to treat “auc­tion pur­chaser” as a single legal cat­egory. At least four re­gimes are in play.

  1. A char­gee’s sale is a sale by a bank or other char­gee ex­er­cising the stat­utory power of sale un­der sec­tions 96 to 99 of the Land Act. The court is not in­volved un­less someone sues. Sec­tion 99 of the Land Act gives the pur­chaser spe­cific stat­utory pro­tec­tion.
  2. A ju­di­cial sale is a sale in ex­e­cu­tion of a court de­cree un­der sec­tions 44, 48 and 49 of the Civil Pro­ced­ure Act (the “CPA”) and Or­der 22 of the Civil Pro­ced­ure Rules, 2010 (the “CPR”), con­duc­ted by a court of­ficer or court-ap­poin­ted auc­tion­eer and con­firmed by the court.
  3. A stat­utory sale by a pub­lic au­thor­ity is a sale by a county gov­ern­ment for un­paid rates or by the Kenya Rev­enue Au­thor­ity for un­paid tax. Un­der the re­pealed Rat­ing Act (Cap. 267), rates sales were in sub­stance ju­di­cial sales; un­der the Na­tional Rat­ing Act, 2024 (the “NRA”) and the Tax Pro­ced­ures Act, 2015 (the “TPA”), the au­thor­ity may sell without a court or­der.
  4. A sale of es­tate prop­erty may take any of these forms, but car­ries the ad­di­tional re­quire­ments of the Law of Suc­ces­sion Act (the “LSA”).

The pro­tec­tion each re­gime gives the pur­chaser is dif­fer­ent, and so is the route by which a sale can be chal­lenged.

Across all four re­gimes the de­cided cases draw the same fun­da­mental line, which we will call “the line between the pro­cess and the root”.

A de­fect in the pro­cess of sale (no­tices, valu­ation, ad­vert­ise­ment, the ne­ces­sity or pro­pri­ety of the sale) is gen­er­ally cured as against an in­no­cent pur­chaser once the sale is com­plete, and the owner is left with dam­ages. That is the policy of sec­tion 99(4) of the Land Act, and it is re­flec­ted in the pro­ced­ure for court sales un­der Or­der 22 of the CPR.

A de­fect in the root (the seller had no valid title, no valid charge, no valid de­cree, or no au­thor­ity to sell) is not cured. The pur­chaser ac­quires only what the seller had to give.

Dina Man­age­ment did not cre­ate that line. It in­tens­i­fied the scru­tiny of the root. Once a court finds that the land was un­law­fully ac­quired at its ori­gin, the auc­tion does not cre­ate an in­terest that did not ex­ist.

Sec­tion 44(1) of the CPA makes “all prop­erty be­long­ing to a judg­ment debtor” li­able to at­tach­ment and sale. Once a sale of im­mov­able prop­erty “has be­come ab­so­lute”, sec­tion 48 of the CPA deems the prop­erty to have ves­ted in the pur­chaser from the time of sale. Or­der 22 rule 77(1) of the CPR provides that the court shall con­firm the sale where no ap­plic­a­tion to set it aside is made or suc­ceeds, “and thereupon the sale shall be­come ab­so­lute in so far as the in­terest of the judg­ment-debtor in the prop­erty sold is con­cerned”.

Two fea­tures of that scheme pro­tect the pur­chaser. First, the pro­ced­ure for chal­len­ging a sale is a closed code. In Stan­ley Ng’ethe Kinyan­jui v Tony Ket­ter & 5 oth­ers [2015] KECA 790 (KLR), the Court of Ap­peal held that the ex­e­cu­tion rules “rep­res­ent a com­plete code” and that a chal­lenger who did not use them could not fall back on the court’s in­her­ent or con­sti­tu­tional powers. The sale was up­held. Secondly, a sale may be set aside for “ma­ter­ial ir­reg­u­lar­ity or fraud in pub­lish­ing or con­duct­ing it” (Or­der 22 rule 75 of the CPR), but only where the ap­plic­ant shows sub­stan­tial in­jury.

The scheme equally lim­its the pur­chaser’s pro­tec­tion. The words “in so far as the in­terest of the judg­ment-debtor in the prop­erty sold is con­cerned” in Or­der 22 rule 77(1) of the CPR mean that con­firm­a­tion passes only what the judg­ment debtor had. Or­der 22 rule 76 of the CPR gives the pur­chaser the right to set the sale aside where “the judg­ment-debtor had no sale­able in­terest”. Where a sale is set aside un­der Or­der 22 rule 75 of the CPR, rule 78 en­titles the pur­chaser to an or­der for re­pay­ment of the pur­chase money, with or without in­terest. In Me­huba Gelan Keul & 2 oth­ers v Ab­dulkadir Shar­iff Ab­dirahim & 4 oth­ers [2015] KEHC 7265 (KLR), an ex­e­cu­tion sale was set aside un­der Or­der 22 rule 75 of the CPR be­cause the prop­erty was already charged to a bank, and the High Court ordered the pur­chaser’s money re­paid with in­terest at 18.5% a year.

Where the pro­ceed­ings be­hind the sale were them­selves void, the pur­chaser takes noth­ing. In Wam­bui v Mwangi & 3 oth­ers [2021] KECA 144 (KLR), land was sold at auc­tion in ex­e­cu­tion of a de­cree fraud­u­lently ob­tained by a plaintiff us­ing an­other per­son’s iden­tity. The Court of Ap­peal held that “no sanc­tion­able be­ne­fits could flow” from the void pro­ceed­ings and that the auc­tion pur­chaser’s title “stood viti­ated by the same nullity”. The sub-pur­chaser lost the land, though the trial court’s money award in its fa­vour against the auc­tion pur­chaser stood. In Dhi­man v Shah [2025] KECA 1264 (KLR), the Court of Ap­peal held that once an ex parte judg­ment was set aside, the auc­tion sale and the vest­ing or­der made on it fell “by op­er­a­tion of law” and were “null and void”. In that case the pur­chaser was the de­cree-holder him­self, so the de­cision does not settle the po­s­i­tion of an un­con­nec­ted bid­der.

Good faith does not al­ways save a ju­di­cial sale even where the de­fect is one of pro­cess. In Na­tion­wide Fin­ance Co Ltd v Meck In­dus­tries Ltd & an­other [2001] KEHC 160 (KLR), the High Court set aside an ex­e­cu­tion sale held without a re­serve price, hold­ing that its power to set aside an ir­reg­u­lar sale is not af­fected by the fact that the prop­erty was sold to a bona fide pur­chaser. The Court of Ap­peal later dis­missed the pur­chaser’s ap­peal, as re­cor­ded in George Gikubu Mbuthia v Con­sol­id­ated Bank of Kenya Lim­ited [2016] KECA 768 (KLR).

Pur­chasers of­ten as­sume that a court doc­u­ment is an an­swer to any later chal­lenge. It is not.

A cer­ti­fic­ate of sale un­der Or­der 22 rule 79 of the CPR re­cords that the sale has be­come ab­so­lute. Sec­tion 65 of the Land Re­gis­tra­tion Act, 2012 (the “LRA”) al­lows a per­son en­titled “by vir­tue of any or­der or cer­ti­fic­ate of sale” to be re­gistered as pro­pri­etor. But the cer­ti­fic­ate re­cords the sale of the judg­ment-debt­or’s in­terest; it does not en­large it.

Vest­ing or­ders are more prob­lem­atic. In Elec­trical Mar­ket­ing (Whole­sale) Ltd v Nairobi City County & 2 oth­ers [2019] KEELC 1982 (KLR), the En­vir­on­ment and Land Court ob­served that vest­ing or­ders are made “with a view to vest­ing mov­able prop­erty on a pur­chaser”, and that “a vest­ing or­der ought not to have been is­sued after the sale of the land”. It set aside the sale and the vest­ing or­der to­gether. Dhi­man shows that a vest­ing or­der falls with the de­cree that sup­ports it.

Sec­tion 25(1) of the LRA pro­tects rights ac­quired “by an or­der of court”, but only “ex­cept as provided in this Act”, which leaves sec­tion 26(1)(b) avail­able. A vest­ing or­der or cer­ti­fic­ate of sale does not cure a de­fect in the root of title.

Un­til 24th Decem­ber 2024, rates were en­forced un­der the Rat­ing Act (Cap. 267). A rat­ing au­thor­ity sued in the sub­or­din­ate court and ex­ecuted the de­cree un­der the CPA, or ap­plied to the High Court for an or­der for sale. Rates sales were there­fore ju­di­cial sales, and the courts set them aside where the stat­utory steps were missed.

In Elec­trical Mar­ket­ing, the land was sold for rates without proper ser­vice of the sum­mons, no­tice of the judg­ment, a re­gistered pro­hib­it­ory or­der, a valu­ation or pay­ment of the pro­ceeds into court. The court held that there were “ma­ter­ial ir­reg­u­lar­it­ies and fraud in the con­duct of the sale”, and it re­jec­ted the ar­gu­ment that dam­ages were the own­er’s only rem­edy. In Dhanji & an­other v County Gov­ern­ment of Mom­basa & 3 oth­ers [2024] KEELC 6001 (KLR), the County could not show that the de­mand had been served, and the sale had been ad­vert­ised without the no­tice be­ing fixed on the prop­erty. The court held that “a good title did not pass”, up­held the can­cel­la­tion of the pur­chasers’ title, and up­held an award of KES 5 mil­lion in dam­ages for the own­er’s wrong­ful evic­tion. The trial court had found that the pur­chasers knew of the pending pro­ceed­ings.

The NRA (No. 15 of 2024) re­pealed Cap. 267. Sec­tion 19(3)(d) of the NRA now al­lows a county, after de­mand and de­fault, to auc­tion the rate­able prop­erty at the cur­rent mar­ket value in ac­cord­ance with the provided pro­ced­ures, with the de­tails left to county le­gis­la­tion (sec­tion 19(4)). Sec­tion 40(5) of the TPA sim­il­arly al­lows the Com­mis­sioner of the Kenya Rev­enue Au­thor­ity to dis­pose of prop­erty charged for un­paid tax by pub­lic auc­tion or private treaty without a court or­der.

Two ob­ser­va­tions fol­low from the stat­utes. First, neither Act con­tains a pro­vi­sion like sec­tion 99 of the Land Act pro­tect­ing the pur­chaser from ir­reg­u­lar­it­ies, so the pur­chaser de­pends on the au­thor­ity’s strict com­pli­ance. Secondly, a sale that de­parts from the stat­utory steps is ex­posed to chal­lenge as a title “ac­quired ... un­pro­ced­ur­ally” un­der sec­tion 26(1)(b) of the LRA. Pur­chasers at county auc­tions should there­fore sat­isfy them­selves that the de­mand was prop­erly served, the no­tice period ex­pired, the prop­erty was val­ued, and the county’s own pro­ced­ure was fol­lowed.

Land of a de­ceased per­son can­not be sold by any­one who lacks a grant (sec­tion 45 of the LSA), and an ad­min­is­trator may not sell im­mov­able prop­erty be­fore the grant is con­firmed (sec­tion 82(b), pro­viso (ii)). Sec­tion 93 of the LSA pro­tects trans­fers made to a pur­chaser “by a per­son to whom rep­res­ent­a­tion has been gran­ted”, even if the grant is later re­voked, but on its terms it does not pro­tect sales by a per­son without a grant.

The courts have ap­plied Dina Man­age­ment to such sales. In Mbae & an­other v Mwamba & 5 oth­ers [2024] KEELC 215 (KLR), land was re­gistered by trans­mis­sion to a per­son who held no grant of rep­res­ent­a­tion, then sub­divided and sold. The court held that the trans­fers were “un­law­ful and can­not be pro­tec­ted by the law”, and, cit­ing Dina Man­age­ment and Torino En­ter­prises Ltd v At­tor­ney Gen­eral [2023] KESC 79 (KLR), that “the bar has been set higher for in­no­cent pur­chasers”. An ap­peal against that de­cision is pending in the Court of Ap­peal. In the char­gee con­text, the Court of Ap­peal in Marteve Guest House Ltd v Njenga & 3 oth­ers [2022] KECA 539 (KLR) held, by a ma­jor­ity, that a bank’s auc­tion was void where the chargor had died, the stat­utory no­tices had been served on her be­ne­fi­ciar­ies be­fore they had ob­tained a grant, and fraud by the bank and the bor­rower was proved. Part 5 dis­cusses that case.

For any pub­lic sale, the pur­chaser should ask two sep­ar­ate ques­tions, and should not let a pos­it­ive an­swer to the first stand in for the second.

  1. Was the sale prop­erly au­thor­ised and con­duc­ted? For a court sale: a valid de­cree, a re­gistered pro­hib­it­ory or­der over the same land, a no­ti­fic­a­tion of sale, a re­serve price based on a cur­rent valu­ation, and con­firm­a­tion by the court. For a rates or tax sale: de­mand, ser­vice, ex­piry of the no­tice period, valu­ation and the pre­scribed pro­ced­ure. For es­tate land: a grant, con­firmed where a sale is in­volved.
  2. Did the seller (the judg­ment debtor, the rate­payer or the de­ceased) have a law­ful title to be­gin with? That re­quires the same root-of-title in­quiry as any private pur­chase: the re­gister and its his­tory, the al­lot­ment and sur­vey re­cords for al­loc­ated land, and in­spec­tion of the land for pub­lic use or third-party oc­cu­pa­tion (Part 7).

The fall of the ham­mer still pro­tects the auc­tion buyer, but only against what went wrong at the auc­tion. It does not cure what was wrong be­fore it: a seller with no title, a void de­cree, es­tate land sold without a grant, or a county that skipped the stat­utory steps. A cer­ti­fic­ate of sale or a vest­ing or­der will not change that. Bar­gains at auc­tion are real, and so are the risks hid­den be­hind them.

Part 5: Char­gee Sales and Sec­tion 99 of the Land Act. The bank sale the Su­preme Court has agreed to de­cide, and what its an­swer could mean for every auc­tion buyer and lender.

Follow the series

Get the next part of "Who Owns the Land?" and our other in­sights by email as soon as they are pub­lished.

Topics (optional):
You'll be subscribed straight away and we'll email you a confirmation. Unsubscribe at any time with one click.

Related insights

Tell us about your matter

A part­ner re­views every re­quest and comes back to you.

Submit a request